Access BordeauxAt dusk the Bourse stands twice, once on the quay and once in the water.
What does the Monument aux Girondins commemorate?
THE COLUMN AT THE QUINCONCES

What does the Monument aux Girondins commemorate?

The story behind the tall column at the Quinconces, the Girondin deputies it honors, and its empty niches.

Photo: Lockx3r, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Home · Journal

THE COLUMN AT THE QUINCONCES

What does the Monument aux Girondins commemorate?

From the page The Esplanade des Quinconces and the Monument aux Girondins

The story behind the tall column at the Quinconces, the Girondin deputies it honors, and its empty niches.

The answer in full

Read on

Who the Girondins were

The column that dominates the Quinconces honors the Girondins, the deputies of the Revolution who came from the Gironde and their political allies in the National Convention. They were a moderate faction, associated with free trade and a looser federal vision of the Republic, and when the Terror turned against the Convention's rivals many of them were sent to the guillotine. Their fall was swift, and for decades afterward their memory was a matter of politics rather than consensus.

The Esplanade des Quinconces and the Monument aux Girondins
The Esplanade des Quinconces and the Monument aux GirondinsDennis G. Jarvis, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

Bordeaux voted to raise a monument to them only in 1881, nearly a century after their deaths, at a moment when the young Third Republic wanted to claim the Revolution's history for itself and when the city wanted a prominent place in that national memory. The choice of site was obvious: the vast open ground of the Quinconces, cleared decades earlier where a royal fortress had once stood, gave the monument room to be seen from a long way off.

From two projects to one

The commission did not go smoothly. A design was chosen in the competition but then set aside in favor of one by the sculptor Alphonse Dumilatre and the architect Victor Rich. Around the same time, the city had separately commissioned a monumental fountain from the sculptor Bartholdi, then backed out when the cost looked too high; Lyon bought the fountain instead, and it stands there today rather than in Bordeaux.

The Esplanade des Quinconces and the Monument aux Girondins
The Esplanade des Quinconces and the Monument aux GirondinsRomainbehar, Wikimedia Commons, CC0

Rather than lose the fountain idea altogether, Bordeaux folded the two abandoned schemes into one project. The result is the monument seen today: a single column rising from a wide base that incorporates two fountains, one on each side. Construction began in 1894 behind a wooden scaffold that was itself fifty-four meters high, taller than the finished monument would eventually be, and the work went on for the better part of a decade, finishing in 1902.

The column and its figures

The column itself stands forty-three meters tall, and at the full height of fifty-four meters a green bronze figure called the Spirit of Liberty breaks its chains at the top, visible from well down the esplanade and from the quays. The two fountains built into the base face in different directions and tell different stories rather than repeating the same theme. The one looking toward the Grand Théâtre shows the Triumph of the Republic, a chariot drawn by sea horses trampling figures representing Ignorance, Falsehood, and Vice underfoot; the one facing the Chartrons quarter shows the Triumph of Concord instead, a gentler companion piece.

The Esplanade des Quinconces and the Monument aux Girondins
The Esplanade des Quinconces and the Monument aux GirondinsLockx3r, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

The sides toward the river and toward the city carry their own groups again. Toward the Garonne, a Gallic cockerel stands on a speaker's rostrum flanked by figures representing History and Eloquence, a reminder that the Girondins were above all orators. Toward the city, a personification of Bordeaux sits on the prow of a ship holding a horn of plenty, with figures of the Dordogne and the Garonne rivers beside her, a nod to the two rivers that meet to form the Gironde estuary downstream. The whole base rewards a slow walk around it rather than a single glance from the front, since no one face shows the full program.

What is missing

The Esplanade des Quinconces and the Monument aux Girondins
The Esplanade des Quinconces and the Monument aux GirondinsDennis G. Jarvis, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

Look closely at the base and the gaps are as telling as the figures that are there. Groups of statues representing eight named Girondin deputies were planned from the very start of the project and never made, whether for cost, time, or changing taste; their intended places on the base are still empty, a permanent sketch of a program that was never finished. A visitor who knows to look for them will notice the bare stone where sculpture was meant to stand.

The bronzes that were made had their own disruption decades later. The occupying army removed them in August 1943 to be melted down for metal, a fate shared by many bronze monuments across occupied France at the time. The foundry in Angers that received them kept them intact instead of melting them, and they were returned after the war, in 1945. They then spent years sitting in port warehouses before finally being reinstalled on the monument in 1983, nearly forty years after they were taken down. A plaque naming eight Girondin deputies was added later still, in 1989, filling in with words what the empty bases on the monument never filled in stone.

Seeing it today

The Esplanade des Quinconces and the Monument aux Girondins
The Esplanade des Quinconces and the Monument aux GirondinsDennis G. Jarvis, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

There is nothing to book to see the monument; it stands in the open square and can be approached from any direction. Walking from the column down the long slope to the two rostral columns and the quay takes about ten minutes, and it is worth allowing another twenty minutes to circle the fountains properly, since the figures on each side reward a close look rather than a passing glance from a distance.

The light favors morning and late afternoon for anyone wanting to photograph the bronze figure at the top of the column, when the sun angle picks out the green patina against the sky. For the single best view of the whole composition, walk down to the river end and look back uphill from beside the rostral columns, with the column centered at the top of the long slope and the esplanade's rows of trees framing it on either side. The square's tram stop, where several lines meet, makes a practical starting or finishing point for the visit; see getting around for how the network and its stops work. The Grand Théâtre is a short walk south for anyone continuing the visit into Saint-Pierre.

An honest note

The Esplanade des Quinconces and the Monument aux Girondins
The Esplanade des Quinconces and the Monument aux GirondinsGrand Parc - Bordeaux, France from France, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

Not everyone in Bordeaux has admired the result. The writer François Mauriac thought the monument's proportions were disastrous, and his verdict is worth repeating precisely because the monument is so often praised uncritically in passing; it is fair to treat the question as one of taste rather than settled fact. Whatever one makes of the sculpture itself, the empty niches on the base and the names added only in 1989 are a reminder that the monument's history, like the political memory it was built to honor, took far longer to settle than the century between the Girondins' deaths and the first vote to commemorate them.

We do not book anything. Access Bordeaux is a guide: it does not sell, book or reserve anything and handles no payments. Some links lead to travel companies, and some of those are affiliate links that may earn this site a commission at no extra cost to you. Any booking you make is between you and that company, under its own terms, and this site is not a party to it.